POLL: Symmetry or not symmetry — that is the question 5

So I finally finished the long awaited Denon DJ MCX8000 review. And the very first comment on Facebook was this:

Screen Shot 2016-06-29 at 15.34.14

…which very neatly segues me into a question that I’ve been meaning to ask for ever and a day, and one that I’ve never seen asked anywhere else — do you prefer symmetrical or non-symmetrical (asymmetrical) controller layout?

What do I mean? This diagram should make it easy to understand:

POLL: Symmetry or not symmetry — that is the question 6

I come from a turntable background, so you’d reasonably expect that I’d go with asymmetrical. But I’m really not bothered as far as controllers goes. It’s probably down to using an ever-changing variety of tech doing DJWORX. I’ve told the story a few times but once more won’t hurt — I was reviewing a Pioneer controller, and messed up more often than normal as I kept nudging the pitch fader on the left deck. My daughter, being a chip off the old block, shouted “I thought you could DJ?”. But generally speaking, I prefer asymmetrical.

I’m sure that there’s a heap of left/right brain coordination research (head patting and tummy rubbing)that I could dig into, as well as thinking that muscle memory has something to do with it too. And I also wonder how long manufacturers agonised about symmetry or asymmetry too.

So I made a poll, which I think will help get a clearer picture:

Controller layouts — what do you prefer?

  • View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...

    This is more out of personal interest, but it’s also useful information for the industry too. So if you use a controller, please add your vote. Ta very much.


    Commenting Etiquette

    Welcome to DJWORX. It’s the most engaged community around, and we have a handful of house rules to keep it that way:
    • • Be polite and constructive.
    • • Treat others as you would expect to be treated. So please disengage keyboard warrior mode before hammering in a full caps rant.
    • • Stay on topic.
    • • Consider your tone of voice. Telling someone that they’re wrong comes across better as “I don’t agree and here’s why”.
    • • No links to copyrighted or offensive material.
    Life is way too short to waste time policing comments. So break the rules and you’re out. It’s just the internet, and  the DJWORX community is way more important than catering to the fragile egos of ranting trolls. I trust I have been crystal clear.